An Extra Slice Of New York

Located in Manor, PA, An Extra Slice Of New York brings an authentic slice of classic New York pizza culture right to the heart of the region. Specializing in traditional NY-style and Sicilian pizzas, this charming pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone craving that perfect balance of crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and robust flavors.

Their menu is delightfully simple yet thoughtfully crafted, featuring two main pizza styles: the iconic Regular Pizza available in 12" (4 slices) and 18" (8 slices) sizes at $11.00 and $21.00 respectively, and the thicker, denser Sicilian Pizza, also offered in 12" and 18" sizes with 4 slices at $21.00 and 9 slices at $36.00. These are not your average pies — each bite boasts a crunchy semolina crust paired with authentic San Marzano tomato sauce and rich, whole milk mozzarella that melts perfectly across the golden base.

For those drawn to more indulgent specialties, their lineup of dough rolls stands out with inventive flavor profiles. The Pepperoni and Sausage rolls mix wholesome mozzarella, olive oil, grated Romano, garlic, and fresh basil to create a savory explosion of taste, each priced at $18.00. Meatball & Ricotta dough rolls ramp up the comforting factor with hearty meatballs and creamy ricotta for $21.00, while the Chicken Parmesan option delivers seasoned, breaded chicken breast atop a bed of plum tomato sauce sure to satisfy fans of classic Italian-American fare.

Step inside An Extra Slice Of New York, and you’ll immediately get a sense of genuine warmth and hospitality. Customers rave about the friendly, attentive staff who go above and beyond — from offering complimentary Italian soup to personalizing each order to perfection. The atmosphere strikes a beautiful balance: bustling yet inviting, casual yet attentive, it’s the kind of place that makes you feel like a regular from your very first visit.

Patrons consistently praise the quality and authenticity here, with many noting that this is the best pizza they’ve found in Pennsylvania, capturing the true essence of New York with every slice. One reviewer enthused about the “amazing crunchy semolina crust” and “quality mozzarella cheese,” while another highlighted the “72-hour ferment” dough that yields a perfectly soft yet crispy crust that stays light and digestible. The care taken in ingredient selection is palpable — featuring Northern California tomatoes and high-grade cheeses — which truly elevates the taste above typical local offerings.

Whether you’re a devoted New Yorker longing for a taste of home or simply an ardent pizza lover seeking something extraordinary, An Extra Slice Of New York delivers an authentic, flavorful, and unforgettable pizza experience. With its artfully crafted pizzas, inviting atmosphere, and heartfelt service, it stands out as a culinary gem in the Manor area that delights both locals and visitors alike.

For an order or inquiry, give them a call at +1 724-861-0818, and get ready to savor pizza perfected with passion and tradition.